×

Service Online

💬 WhatsApp: +86 18011793320
💬
  • Home
  • Blogs
  • Film Coating vs Sugar Coating vs Enteric Coating: Tablet Coating Methods Insights

Film Coating vs Sugar Coating vs Enteric Coating: Tablet Coating Methods Insights

Tablet coating is a critical step in modern pharmaceutical manufacturing, with three main types of tablet coating methods widely used today, which are sugar coating, film coating, and enteric coating. This article delves into the various methods used to coated tablets, analyse the differences, advantages and disadvantages, machines that applied for the coating process as well as how to choose the right tablet coating machine.

 

 

1. What Are Sugar Coat, Film Coating and Enteric Coating?

 

  • Sugar Coat: Sugar coating meaning the methodof applying multiple layers of sucrose-based syrup, often with added colorants and polishing wax, to enhance appearance and mask bitter tastes. This traditional method results in sugar coated tablets with a smooth, glossy finish. Although visually appealing, the sugar coating process of tablets is time-consuming and significantly increases tablet weight and size.
  • Film Coating: Film coating for tablets uses a thin layer of polymeric film, typically applied using a tablet coating machine or automatic tablet coating machine. It protects tablets from moisture, improves swallowability, and allows for color branding. Film coatings are fast-drying and ideal for high-speed production.
  • Enteric Coating: Enteric-coated tablets are formulated with special pH-sensitive polymers that prevent the drug from dissolving in the acidic environment of the stomach. Instead, they dissolve in the higher pH of the intestines. This protects drugs that may be degraded by stomach acid or irritate the gastric lining.

 

 

2. Examples of Sugar Coated, Film Coated, and Enteric Coated Tablet in Pharmaceuticals

 

Tablet coating methods, ie. sugar coating, film tablet coating, and enteric coating, serves specific purposes. Below is a comparison of their most common applications, benefits and examples in the pharmaceutical industry.

Coating Type Common Applications Benefits Example Tablets
Sugar Coated Tablets Multivitamins, supplements, pediatric formulations Masks unpleasant taste, attractive appearance, improves intake Multivitamin tablets, chewables tablets for kids, etc.
Film Coated Tablets Daily wellness tablets, routine medications Enhanced durability, moisture protection, easier swallowing General wellness supplements
Enteric Coated Tablets Stomach-sensitive formulations, enzymes, probiotics Targeted release in intestines, gastric protection Digestive support, enzyme-based or timed-release tablets

 

3. Sugar Coating vs Enteric Coating vs Film Coating: Key Differences

 

Sugar coating, film coating, and enteric coating serves distinct pharmaceutical purposes. Here below are their differences.

Feature Sugar Coating Film Coating Enteric Coating
Purpose Improves taste and appearance Protects tablet, improves swallowability Delays release until reaching intestines
Thickness Thick (30–50% weight gain) Thin (2–3% weight gain) Thin to moderate, pH-dependent polymer
Ingredients Sucrose, colorants, food-grade waxes Cellulose-based polymers, plasticizers (e.g. PEG), approved pigments and opacifiers Gastro-resistant polymers (e.g. methacrylic acid copolymers, pH-sensitive cellulose)
Processing Time Long, labor-intensive Short, efficient Moderate, requires pH-sensitive coating
Moisture Sensitivity Not ideal for moisture-sensitive drugs Suitable for most drugs Protects acid-sensitive ingredients
Surface Finish Glossy, smooth Matte or colored Opaque, protective finish
Applications Multivitamins, herbal tablets OTC meds, supplements Acid-labile or stomach-irritating drugs

 

 

4. Sugar Coating vs Enteric Coating vs Film Coating: Pros and Cons

 

Coating Type Advantages Disadvantages
Sugar Coating – Excellent taste masking for bitter drugs

– Glossy, attractive tablet coating

– Improves patient compliance especially for pediatrics

– Protects from moisture and light

– Increases tablet size and weight

– Longer and more complex sugar coating process

– Requires skilled operators and more tablet coating equipment

– Not ideal for moisture-sensitive drugs

Film Coating – Thin, light film coating adds minimal bulk- Faster and more efficient tablet film coating process

– Suitable for high-speed automatic tablet coating machines

– Flexible for taste masking, branding, or controlled release

– Common in pharmaceutical production

– May not fully mask strong tastes or odors

– Requires precise formulation and process control

– Risk of poor adhesion or cracking if misapplied

Enteric Coating – Protects drug from gastric acid degradation

– Shields stomach from irritation

– Enables targeted release in the intestine

– Suitable for acid-sensitive APIs and certain antibiotics

– More complex and costly film coating process

– Longer processing time

– Delayed onset of drug action

– Not for drugs needing rapid absorption

 

Additional Considerations:

  • Film coated tablets vs sugar coated tablets: Film coatings offer a thinner, more efficient layer suitable for mass production, while sugar coatings provide better flavor and appearance but are less practical at scale.
  • Enteric coated tablets vs film coated tablets: Enteric coatings provide targeted drug delivery to the intestines, while film coatings are used mainly for protection and branding.

 

 

5. Why Are Sugar, Film, and Enteric Coatings Important?

 

Tablet coating whether sugar coating, film coating, or enteric coatingis vital in pharmaceutical manufacturing. Here below are some major reasons of tablet coating.

    • Protection: Coated tablets offer a protective layer that shields the active pharmaceutical ingredient (API)from environmental factors like moisture, light, and oxygen. For example, film coating for tablets provides a thin, effective barrier without increasing tablet size significantly, while sugar coating of tablets is useful for moisture-sensitive drugs due to its thick, glossy layer.
    • Taste Masking: Unpleasant-tasting drugs are easier to swallow when coated. Sugar coated tablets and film coated tablets are especially valuable in taste masking, making them ideal for pediatric and geriatric patients.
    • Controlled Release: Enteric-coated tablets are designed to bypass the stomach and dissolve in the intestine. This helps protect acid-sensitive drugs and prevents stomach irritation. It’s essential for drugs with delayed release requirements, such as certain antibiotics and pain medications.
    • Patient Compliance: Colorful coated tablets, whether sugar coated, film coated, or enteric coated, can enhance visual appeal and are easier for patients to recognize and remember. This leads to better medication adherenceand reinforces brand identity. Examples include film coated pills with vibrant hues using tablet coating equipment.
    • Differentiation and Functionality: Coatings help distinguish between coated vs non coated tablets, making them easier to identify. They also enable the use of coating tablet types for extended or modified release, aiding in complex drug delivery systems.

 

 

6. Coated vs Non-Coated Tablets: Whats the Differences?

 

When choosing the right dosage form, understanding the difference between coated and non-coated tablets is essential. Each has its own advantages depending on the formulation goals.

Feature Coated Tablets Non-Coated Tablets
Definition Tablets with a protective layer such as film coating, sugar coating, or enteric coating Plain compressed tablets without any external coating
Taste Masking Effectively masks unpleasant flavors (especially in sugar coated tablets and film coated tablets) May have bitter or unpleasant taste
Ease of Swallowing Coated tablets (especially film coated pills) are smoother and easier to swallow Often rougher and harder to ingest
Protection from Environment Coatings protect from moisture, light, and oxidation Less stable in humid or light-exposed conditions
Release Control Enteric coated tablets and film coating for tablets allow for targeted or delayed release Immediate release only, no control over where/when drug is released
Manufacturing Complexity Requires tablet coating machine, more production steps Simpler and more cost-effective to produce
Patient Compliance Better patient experience due to taste, look, and ease Lower compliance due to bitter taste and harder swallowing

 

 

7. Coated vs Non-Coated Tablets: Which One to Choose for Manufacturing?

 

When deciding between coated and non-coated tablets, manufacturers must consider several factors, including tablet coating process, formulation goals, cost, and patient experience. Here is a quick guide:

 

Choose Coated Tablets If:

    • You need taste masking(e.g., sugar coating tablets or film coated tablets).
    • Your product requires protection from moisture, light, or oxidation.
    • You want controlled or delayed drug release(via enteric coating or film coating on tablets).
    • You’re aiming for higher patient complianceand market appeal.
    • You plan to use tablet coating machinesfor large-scale production.

 

Choose Non-Coated Tablets If:

    • Your formula is stable and doesn’t require extra protection.
    • You want to reduce manufacturing costs.
    • Your product does not need taste maskingor controlled release.
    • You’re producing simple, immediate-release formulations.

 

8. Tablet Pressing and Tablet Coating Machinery Guide

 

Producing high-quality film coated tablets, sugar coated tablets, or enteric coated tablets starts with the right equipment. In pharmaceutical manufacturing, two key machines work hand-in-hand: the tablet press machine and the tablet coating machine.

 

1) Tablet Press Machine: Core of Tablet Manufacturing

Tablet presses are responsible for compressing powder into solid tablets. Whether you’re making coated tablets or non-coated tablets, a tablet compression machine must ensure accurate dosage, hardness, and uniformity. For companies aiming to produce film coated pills or sugar coated multivitamin tablets, starting with a consistent tablet core is critical.

 

 

Here is one highly recommended high speed rotary tablet press machine – ZP26/40D Tablet Press Machine from Jinlu Packing with the key features of:

 

    • High Speed High Performance: Ideal for mass production of film coated tablets, sugar coated tablets, and enteric coated tablets, the ZP26/40D ensures consistent output with up to 260,000 tablets per hour.
    • Durable Components and Parts: Built with stainless steel and high-grade materials, this tablet compression machine guarantees long-term stability even in continuous operations.
    • Pre-Pressing Function: A dedicated pre-compression stage reduces air entrapment, improves powder flow, and enhances tablet hardness uniformity.
    • Real Time Pressure Monitoring: Advanced sensors monitor tablet compression force during production, ensuring optimal hardness and reducing defects.
    • Single Piece Waste Rejection: The system identifies and rejects faulty tablets individually, minimizing waste and maintaining batch quality.

 

2) Tablet Coating Machine: Essential for Functional & Aesthetic Coatings

 

After pressing, tablets are sent to the tablet coating machine. Coating serves several functions:

    • Film coating masks taste and improves appearance.
    • Sugar coating enhances visual appeal and patient compliance.
    • Enteric coating protects drugs from stomach acid and allows delayed release in the intestine.

 

 

 

If you are looking for a reliable and high-performance tablet coating machine, this high speed tablet coater from Jinlu Packing is engineered for precision film coating, sugar coating, and enteric coating applications, with some more key features as below:

    • Automatic Coating Control System: This auto coater tablet coating machineoffers precise adjustment of spray rate, pan speed, and temperature, ensuring a uniform film coated tablet finish every batch.
    • Versatile Coating Capabilities: Suitable forfilm coating, sugar coating tablets, and enteric-coated tablets, this machine supports a wide range of pharmaceutical formulations.
    • Touch Screen PLC Interface: User-friendly operation with real-time monitoring, batch recording, and automated control, perfect for both small batch runs and mass production.
    • High Coating Uniformity: Special spray gun design and baffle system provide even coating distribution, minimizing defects and reducing the chance of coating tablet rejection.

 

9. Conclusion

As the three major tablet coating methods in pharmaceuticals, sugar coating, film coating and also enteric coating have their own key advantages. Sugar coated tablets improve taste and appearance, film coated tablets offer fast, efficient protection,while enteric coated tablets ensure delayed release in the intestine. Choosing the right method depends on the drug, target release, and patient needs. With the right tablet coating machine and tablet press, you can produce high-quality coated tablets that stand out in the market.

 

Share this Article:

Table of Contents

Related Post

Get A Free Quote

*We respect your confidentiality and all data is protected. Your personal data will only be used and processed for JL solution.